How the ratings work

Data: the DVSA's MOT history for Great Britain, snapshot 2026-11-15: 640,812,995 first MOT tests of 77,770,299 vehicles.

Which tests count

Only the first test of each MOT. A retest after a failure is part of the same MOT and is not counted again, so a car that fails and is fixed counts once, as a fail. "Pass first time" means the vehicle passed with no failure items; a pass after repairs during the test (PRS) counts as a fail.

Comparing like with like

Older, higher-mileage vehicles fail more often, and some models are mostly bought by people who cover big miles. A raw pass rate mixes all that up. So for every test we work out how often comparable vehicles fail: same body type (car, van, motorcycle), same year of first registration, same age and same mileage band. The relative fail rate is the number of fails a model actually had divided by the number expected from comparable vehicles. 0.80 means it fails 20% less often than comparable vehicles; 1.25 means 25% more often.

Age is years since first registration. For imported vehicles we use the original registration date when it is known. Mileage comes from cleaned odometer readings; readings that go backwards, jump impossibly or were entered in kilometres are corrected or left out.

How sure we are

Every rate comes with a 95% range (Wilson interval). With few tests the range is wide. We show a model only with at least 100 first MOT tests, and ask search engines to index it only with at least 1,000.

Verdicts

  • Much more reliable than average (“Much better” in tables): the whole 95% range is below 0.80.
  • More reliable than average (“Better”): the whole range is below 0.95.
  • About average (“Average”): the range sits within 0.90–1.10.
  • Less reliable / much less reliable (“Worse” / “Much worse”): the whole range is above 1.05 / 1.25.
  • Not enough evidence (“Unclear”): none of these, usually because the range is wide.

Gems

A gem is a vehicle you can realistically buy: at least 5,000 first MOT tests, 10,000 vehicles tested and 2,000 still on the road, with tests at three or more ages. Models are ranked within their class (city cars against city cars, vans against vans), by the upper end of their 95% range, so a gem needs both a good result and plenty of evidence. In each class the top five with the whole range below 0.95 are gems. Each model appears once, as the whole model or as its best generation. Rare exotics (Ferrari, Bentley and so on) are left out: they cover few miles and are usually maintained regardless of cost.

High mileage

Every first MOT is placed in a mileage band (0–20k, 20–40k … 150–200k, 200k+) from the cleaned odometer reading; tests with an unreliable reading are left out of the mileage views. For each band we show the model's first-time pass rate next to the pass rate of comparable vehicles with the same mileage band, age and year of first registration, so high-mileage cars being older does not distort the picture.

The high-mileage verdict uses all tests at 100,000+ miles (and separately 150,000+), with the same thresholds as the main verdict and at least 1,000 tests at that mileage. Comparing it with the same figure under 60,000 miles shows whether a model keeps, loses or gains ground as the miles rise. The best high-mileage buys meet the gem rules and have at least 3,000 tests at 100,000+ miles.

High-mileage cars are often motorway or company cars and some are better looked after, so this describes how cars at that mileage actually do at their MOT, not how a particular engine will wear.

What fails

Failure items are grouped into areas (brakes, tyres, lights, suspension, corrosion…) by their DVSA description. For each area we show the share of first MOTs with at least one failure item there, and how that compares with comparable vehicles: the same body type, year of first registration, age and mileage band, as for the overall rating. Tester notes ("user entered" free text) are not counted as defects.

What the ratings don't tell you

  • The MOT checks safety and emissions, not everything that can go wrong. A gearbox or electrical fault that doesn't affect the MOT is not in this data.
  • We adjust for age and mileage, not for how owners look after their vehicles. Cars that are often well maintained look better.
  • Electric cars are new: few are older than ten years. Where an electric model fails more often than comparable cars, the extra failures are mostly tyres and suspension (they are heavy); their brakes and lights fail less often than average. Compare them with care.
  • A rating describes the model on average, not the car in front of you. Always check that vehicle's own MOT history.

Not official DVSA guidance. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.