Proton Gen-2 reliability

First registered 2004–2012 · 45,732 MOT tests

Much less reliable than average

The Proton Gen-2 fails its MOT 37% more often than comparable cars.

95% range: 35–38% more often. Compared with comparable cars of the same age, mileage and year of first registration, on 45,732 first MOT tests of vehicles first registered 2004–2012.

Relative fail rate 1.37 (95% range 1.35–1.38); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles

fails less oftenmore often

At 100,000+ miles: fails 37% more often than comparable cars at that mileage Much worse

63%
pass their MOT first time (62.4%–63.3%)
5,242
vehicles MOT-tested, 304 still on the road
6,500 miles
typical miles a year
19%
reached 100,000 miles and 2% reached 150,000

MOT pass rate by age

Share of first MOT tests each year (not retests) that passed with no failure items.

The dashed line is all cars of the same age, whatever their mileage. The verdict above also matches mileage and year of first registration, so the two can differ; pass rate by mileage compares like with like.

Proton Gen-295% rangeAll cars of the same age
40%50%60%70%80%90% 35791113151719 Age at MOT (years) 40%50%60%70%80%90% 369121518 Age at MOT (years)
Show as a table: pass rate by age
AgePass first time95% rangeAll cars of the same ageTests
378.0%76.9%–79.1%86.2%5,143
475.5%74.3%–76.7%83.7%5,034
571.3%70.0%–72.5%80.1%4,930
665.1%63.7%–66.4%76.4%4,816
763.2%61.8%–64.6%72.7%4,569
858.6%57.1%–60.1%68.9%4,246
956.7%55.1%–58.3%65.3%3,822
1051.0%49.3%–52.8%62.0%3,301
1151.1%49.2%–53.0%59.2%2,703
1251.0%48.9%–53.2%56.9%2,145
1350.5%48.1%–53.0%55.3%1,557
1452.8%49.9%–55.6%54.2%1,139
1550.0%46.6%–53.4%53.7%826
1650.5%46.5%–54.5%53.5%590
1751.1%46.2%–56.0%53.8%393
1850.5%43.9%–57.1%54.2%216
1950.4%41.5%–59.3%54.9%117

Buying a high-mileage Proton Gen-2

Much less reliable than average

At 100,000+ miles the Proton Gen-2 fails 37% more often than comparable cars with the same mileage and age.

  • Under 60,000 miles: fails 40% more often (69% pass first time, 31,464 tests).
  • At 100,000+ miles: fails 37% more often (42% pass first time against 57% for comparable cars, 2,451 tests).

It fails more often than comparable cars at any mileage.

First-time MOT pass rate at each mileage. The dashed line is what comparable cars with the same mileage, age and year of first registration achieve, so the gap between the lines is down to the model, not to how old or well used the cars are.

Proton Gen-295% rangeComparable cars at the same mileage and age
30%50%70%90% 0–20k20–40k40–60k60–80k80–100k100–125k125–150k150–200k Miles at MOT 30%50%70%90% 0–20k40–60k80–100k125–150k Miles at MOT
Show as a table: pass rate by mileage
Miles at testPass first time95% rangeComparableRelative fail rateTests
0–20k81.9%80.9%–82.9%88.6%1.586,026
20–40k71.8%71.0%–72.5%80.0%1.4213,675
40–60k60.2%59.3%–61.1%70.7%1.3611,763
60–80k51.5%50.4%–52.6%63.3%1.327,674
80–100k46.8%45.2%–48.4%58.8%1.293,829
100–125k41.9%39.7%–44.3%57.1%1.351,740
125–150k40.0%35.8%–44.4%57.9%1.43497
150–200k43.6%36.7%–50.8%58.3%1.35188

What fails at high mileage

Share of first MOTs failed in each area: under 60,000 miles, and at 100,000+ miles. The last column compares the 100k+ figure with comparable cars of the same mileage, age and year of first registration.

AreaUnder 60k100k+ milesvs comparable cars at 100k+
Lights & electrics14.0%37.7% +73%
Brakes12.1%28.4% +149%
Suspension4.8%17.5% +16%
Tyres & wheels7.1%14.2% +45%
Exhaust & emissions3.1%9.3% +77%
Windscreen & mirrors5.5%9.1% +46%
Corrosion & structure0.5%5.8% +429%
Seat belts & airbags2.2%5.2% +167%

Best and worst years

How often vehicles first registered in each year fail, against comparable cars of the same age and mileage.

Fails less often than comparable carsFails more often
0.670.801.01.251.50 200420052006200720082009201020112012 Year of first registration 0.670.801.01.251.50 20042006200820102012 Year of first registration

Bars below the line: cars first registered that year fail less often than comparable cars of the same age and mileage. Scale is relative (1.0 = same).

Show as a table: fail rate by year of first registration
First registeredRelative fail rateTests
20041.202,141
20051.2210,296
20061.3510,069
20071.398,657
20081.456,311
20091.523,410
20101.522,635
20111.621,463
20121.74688

What fails

Share of first MOT tests with at least one failure item in each area; 5.3% had a dangerous defect. “vs comparable cars” compares with comparable cars of the same age, mileage and year of first registration.

AreaMOTs failed on itvs comparable cars
Lights & electrics +65%
Brakes +162%
Tyres & wheels +29%
Suspension about the same
Windscreen & mirrors +39%
Exhaust & emissions +87%
Seat belts & airbags +235%
Body & doors +397%
Corrosion & structure +187%
Drive shafts & transmission -15%
Steering -14%
Fuel system +139%
Registration plate & VIN -14%
Engine & leaks +189%

Most common MOT failures

  1. 1Position lamp not working · Lights & electrics5.2% of MOTs
  2. 2Parking brake: efficiency below requirements · Brakes5.1% of MOTs
  3. 3Tyre tread depth below requirements of 1.6mm · Tyres & wheels4.6% of MOTs
  4. 4Windscreen wiper does not clear the windscreen effectively · Windscreen & mirrors4.1% of MOTs
  5. 5Registration plate lamp not working · Lights & electrics4.0% of MOTs
  6. 6Parking brake recording little or no effort · Brakes3.5% of MOTs
  7. 7Headlamp aim too low · Lights & electrics3.0% of MOTs
  8. 8Brake pad less than 1.5 mm thick · Brakes2.8% of MOTs
  9. 9Headlamp aim too high · Lights & electrics2.3% of MOTs
  10. 10Stop lamp not working · Lights & electrics2.2% of MOTs

Other Proton models

Older, higher-mileage vehicles pass less often, so each verdict compares a vehicle with others of the same age and mileage. A newer one can pass more often and still rate worse.

ModelYearsMOTsPass first timevs comparable (1.0 = same)Verdict
Proton Persona 1993–2011 109k 55% Relative fail rate 1.09 (95% range 1.08–1.10); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.09 Worse
Proton Wira 2000–2004 43k 62% Relative fail rate 1.23 (95% range 1.21–1.24); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.23 Worse
Proton Savvy 2006–2012 34k 59% Relative fail rate 1.67 (95% range 1.65–1.69); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.67 Much worse
Proton Satria 1999–2012 28k 59% Relative fail rate 1.38 (95% range 1.36–1.40); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.38 Much worse
Proton 1.5 1989–2005 27k 62% Relative fail rate 0.85 (95% range 0.84–0.87); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 0.85 Better
Proton Jumbuck 2003–2006 22k 62% Relative fail rate 1.13 (95% range 1.11–1.15); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.13 Worse
Proton Impian 2001–2010 21k 62% Relative fail rate 1.24 (95% range 1.22–1.26); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.24 Worse
Proton 1.3 1989–2008 16k 58% Relative fail rate 0.95 (95% range 0.93–0.96); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 0.95 Average